I'm Alan Tannenbaum, the principal of Hill Tannenbaum. I'm here with my partners, Jim Turfs and Taylor Ford. We're going to be talking today about transition from developer control. Send your questions through chat, and we'll get to as many of them as possible.
So I've been doing condo and HOA turnovers actually for 47 years. I started as a young lawyer, 25 years old, and was part of a team that handled turnovers at my initial firm, and I've been doing that on the East Coast and West Coast for all that time, and I've been involved in several hundred turnovers. Jim and Taylor, also in the last several years, have had experience with it. And I'm going to cover first pre-transition.
So pre-transition is the period between the time that the developer forms the association, which is at the inception before there's initial sale, and controls the condo association or HOA or the co-op during the period of sales. And that could be a fairly short period of time, a year to year or two. We have some HOA turnovers that took 20 years. So it all depends on how quickly the units sold, what statute they happen to be under. But the developer controls the board. There may be a seat that's available for a unit owner or a lot owner, but the developer has a majority, makes the decisions, and so forth. And the question is, what should the non-developer owners be doing during the period of developer control?
Well, organization is good. Sometimes the developer actually promotes the formation of a transition committee, maybe even sometimes gives them a budget to work with. But if the developer doesn't do that, it's a good idea for interested owners to get together, form a committee, get organized.
But one thing that's really important to understand, and it's the second point on this slide, that transition committee does not have authority. It can't bind the owners. It can't negotiate a deal with the developer. It should never give the owners the appearance as a transition committee, they're acting with authority. So really important for a transition committee not to overstate their authority when dealing with the owners. Michelle, next slide, please.
Okay, so what is the purpose of a transition committee? Well, asking questions. So you have a right to attend board meetings and the association meeting at the end of the year. You can ask questions. There's some formal provisions in the Condo Act and the HOA Act for submitting written questions. They have to follow certain procedures.
Those questions have to be answered. You're entitled in the period of pre-transition to get association documents from the developer. There's a long list of association records that you're entitled to see. Both statutes have procedures for soliciting that information. With condos, the CPPR has the ability to sanction a developer if they don't turn over documents. You have that avenue.
There's the ability to go to mediation or arbitration if documents are not provided, and there's certain fines under the statute. So, you have the right to get association records during the period of developer control, and there's some backing in the statute and administrative rules to accomplish that.
Now, governmental authorities. So usually the jurisdiction where the property is, it could be a city or could be a county. There's a development order that's been entered. Should get a copy of the development order. You should learn if the developer has posted bonds with the governmental entity and be in contact with the governmental entity about the requirements of those bonds and the development order. And you may be able to educate the governmental entities on what provisions of the development order or the bond requirements are not being met by the developer.
So certainly initiate those conversations. You have no right to hold up the release of the bond, but if you have a motivated governmental entity, they certainly have the right to withhold the release of the bond until the developer's met their obligations. So, your job is to show some interest, point out to the governmental authorities what's in the development order, and persuade them to enforce it.
The other entity that you're going to deal with is the water management district. They have authority. There's an operational permit the developer's got to apply for. It has conditions. You can get all their records. In fact, their records are online.
You can gather all that information, and again, you can be in contact with those authorities about the provisions of their permits that are not being met by the developer. So you can gather information, and you can educate those county, city, and water management district parties about what's happening at your project.
So the next point, proposing a slate. So we have been in a lot of situations where there's a very educated group who's done a lot of hard work pre-transition, and none of them get elected to the initial owner board. And a lot of the value of the work is for naught because they forgot to put the politics in place. So it's really important for that committee or for interested owners to propose a particular slate to run for that owner control board. Politic, get them elected.
Now, what some developers do is they involve themselves in association politics. They find people within the community who they would prefer run for the board, and they engineer those people getting elected. And sometimes it's even a relative of a contractor who worked on the project. It could be a developer employee. We've seen some developer-related people be on that initial board because the owners didn't realize that the developer was engineering a vote to get somebody positive and beneficial for the developer on that initial board.
So the politicking is really important, even if it's door-to-door. Like in any association, most people are not going to be involved and not going to be interested, and you have to find the best way to reach them in order to get them motivated to vote. We warn against sending them too much information. If you drop off a 50-page committee report, you'll probably lose more voters than you'll gain. So any written correspondence should be bullet points, no more than two pages about the things that you want to accomplish and a little bit about your individual backgrounds, your business experience, your management experience, and what motivates you to be on the board and keep it short and sweet.
One of the things that some groups do pre-transition is it's usually fairly easy for a developer to amend your documents, your bylaws, your declaration, prior to turnover. And if it's a fairly innocuous change that's not going to be at the detriment of the developer, sometimes the developer will be willing to do that. So for instance, if there's a three-person board and you want a five-person board, and there's no skin off the developer's back to change to a five-person board before turnover, the developer does that amendment, and then you come into power as a five-person board. It's more difficult, usually, after transition to go through the amendment process. So There may be some operational issues that the developer can help with through amendment that, again, won't detrimentally affect the developer, and they may be willing to go through a much easier amendment process still during the developer control.
Next, please. Okay. I'm going to, at this juncture, turn the program over to my partner, Jim Turfe, who's going to be talking about developer obligations at transition for both condos and HOAs. Jim, you're on.
Good morning, everybody. As Alan said, I'm going to talk to you about what happens. First, what triggers turnover, and then once turnover, as we call it, is officially triggered, what your association needs to do next, what the membership has to do once you've wrested control away from the developer. So as you might have seen in the chat, somebody asked a question about 50% sales for an HOA and would that one trigger. That's touching on what I'm about to discuss.
So turnover, which is the transition from developer control to member control, when the membership takes over the board of directors and actually begins operating the association.
For condominiums to start with is triggered by sales. So the statutes, which we know condominiums are creatures of statutes, so they really control how condos are operated and how turnover occurs for condos. The statutes provide that at least three years after at least 50% of the units that are going to ultimately be operated by the association have been sold. In broad pictures, if 50% of the units have been sold, three years later, the board should turn over. The developer's board of directors should resign, and member directors should be elected.
For condominiums, that's not the only standard. So it's three years after 50%. If before that three years time lapses, the developer sells 90% or more of those units, then within three months, turnover occurs. So three years after 50%, three months after 90%.
Now, there are other events that can also trigger turnover. They're less common these days than they were maybe 10 years ago, 20 years ago, such as foreclosure. If somehow the developer had a lien on the property and it's getting foreclosed, if the developer goes into bankruptcy, things like that can also force turnover earlier than expected. Again, those aren't quite so common these days, so I'm not going to go very deep into them.
But there are two other condominium turnover thresholds that are important and you probably should remember. The first is that once 15% of the units are sold, the members get at least one director on the board. Maybe more, and there could be some circumstances, but the statutes say 15% of the units are sold, one director. So you get your foot in the door. Part of the conversation we had before this meeting started involved somebody who did that, who was the pre-turnover director. And the other important part is no later than seven years after the declaration has been recorded, turnover must occur.
And that comes with a lot of conditions. Again, I don't know that we need to go to that level of detail right here for the sake of educating you, but the rule now is no later than seven years after the declaration has been recorded, turnover must occur for condominiums. HOAs, on the other hand, are not nearly as regulated by statute. Your governing documents apply there, and an HOA declaration is going to include turnover provisions. They're going to have language that says, "This is how turnover occurs." There are some statutory defaults. If a developer didn't put any turnover language in there, they're not going to leave you under developer control forever.
So we do have some statutory defaults, but by and large, it's going to be based on your governing documents. The statutory defaults are, however, once 90% of the units, that are lots, units, properties, that are ultimately going to be controlled by the association are sold 90%, then three months later, turnover has to occur. So just like condos, three months after 90% are sold. You still get that one for an HOA. And you also still have the right to have one director appointed from the membership. So you'll still have a developer board, you get your one member director on there, but instead of 15% sales like condominiums, you're going to need 50% of the units sold for an HOA.
So turnover is a little bit slower for HOAs than it is for condominiums in some regards. It, of course, can be faster. But again, you're primarily looking at your governing documents there to figure out when turnover really occurs for an HOA. So without getting into the minutia of that, we have turnover. Whatever appropriate time has passed after whatever number of units have been sold, now the members have the right to take over the board. That's going to be done by an election.
This is going to be an election process. If you're a condominium, it's dictated by statute. If you're an HOA, it's largely controlled by your documents. But essentially, you're going to hold an open election for the membership. People are going to submit a notice of intent to run. There's going to be an election.
That process is a little different for condos and HOAs. Not going to get into that today either. But essentially, it's a standard election. At that point, however many directors you have, whether that's three directors, five directors, seven directors in some circumstances, they're all going to be elected from the membership at this point as a result of turnover. And so once that's fully triggered and once your membership is in control, and turnover has officially begun, both parties are going to have some continuing obligations. The first of which is records turnover.
So there's a detailed list of records under both Chapter 718 for condominiums and Chapter 720 for HOAs regarding the documents that a developer has to provide to the newly elected member board. Again, I'm not going to read all 20 of them, I think it is, something like that, but there are certainly some key ones that you need to remember. The governing documents must be turned over from the developer to the membership. That's going to be your declaration and any amendments, your bylaws and any amendments, and your articles of incorporation at a bare minimum. If the developer implemented rules, you also need those rules as well. You're also going to have to deal with minutes, the corporate records.
So to the extent your developer was having properly noticed and agenda meetings before turnover, to the extent they were keeping minutes of those meetings, the member board is entitled to get all of those records as well. Basically, you need to know how the association runs, which is the governing documents, and how it has been run historically, which are going to be your meeting minutes and those records of those decisions the board has previously made. As part of the turnover process, you're also going to need to get written resignations of all of the developer's directors. They have to resign as part of that turnover process. So they resign, you have an election. That's how the board transitions.
If they don't resign, technically, they can create some complications. You're going to need a list of all the unit owners. You need the roster. You need to know who owns in your community so that you can make sure they're being assessed properly and do all of that good stuff. It's an official record of the association that you're going to need to maintain going forward. So that roster is going to be very helpful as far as the actual administration of your association going forward.
As far as newly developed communities, you're also going to need all of the permits, certificates of occupancy, warranties, the names, phone numbers, and contact information for every contractor, subcontractor, material man who did any work on the creation of your association. Again, it's frequent. It's very common that there are construction deficiencies in what your developer gives you. They don't always do the world's best job, and there may be issues that need to be addressed right away. Having all that information as far as warranties and the contractors, subcontractors, enables you to assess that. And if you need to go after the developer or seek repairs, that's where you're going to get that information.
Another key item is insurance policies. As you can imagine, you need to make sure that everything that the statutes say you need to insure is insured. That's going to be your common property. For condominiums, it might be structural components of a building and various other items. You might have to have flood insurance if your governing documents call for it. You need to get the insurance information sorted out.
You need to have every policy. And if the policy needs to be amended to represent turnover, you need to get on that immediately. You want to make sure everything is properly covered because we know storms are just a part of living in Florida, and damage is very likely. So getting those insurance policies, getting all that information, and ensuring that they're properly addressed, very key. And of course, you need any contracts that the developer has entered into for your association that you may have to comply with. That might be a CAM contract, it might be a lease for units or something like that.
Whatever contracts they have in place, cable contracts, you need those. Again, they may need to be amended. I'll talk in a minute about perhaps canceling them if that's appropriate under the circumstances. And again, having all of that information is really going to be key to enable the owner directors to do their job, comply with the contracts. If you don't know about a contract, you're going to breach it, and then you're going to get sued. So you want to make sure you have all these documents.
But perhaps some of the most important documents you need to get as part of turnover are the financial records. You need to get the books. You need to get accounts. You need to get all supporting documents for expenditures, invoices, cash receipts, and all that good stuff, because that will take us into the next section I want to talk about, which is audits. At turnover, as part of those records, you're also going to need to have an accountant audit all of the financials.
Now, that may be an audit of the financial records going all the way back to the creation of the association. If the developer was actually conducting annual audits as they ran it, you may only need an audit that goes back to the last audit they had done. So hopefully they've been doing their job, but if not, you're going to want to get a CPA in there. They have to use generally accepted accounting principles and use generally accepted accounting standards and all this good stuff. We are not accountants, and I will not tell you what any of that means. But by and large, they're checking out to make sure that your developer didn't under-assess, didn't use your money for projects that weren't related to your development, leave you under-reserved, whatever it may be.
Again, I think somebody in the chat mentioned how important an audit is. Again, it is because you need to make sure you have the money that enables you to actually operate your association. And the developer has a lot of different methods by which they can try to short you. And it's very important to ensure that you get the money that you need. That audit is key. So next up is going to be the engineering reports.
And again, it's referenced here for condos because it's a primary concern. A condo association is responsible for maintaining the common elements, the structure, and various specific components of condominium buildings. The engineering report we're talking about here is more of a budgetary tool. It's an inspection that's going to go through, take a look at every common element, every component of a building, or the property, that the condominium is responsible for maintaining. And it's going to say, "Hey, this is the estimated useful life. This is what you need to start saving for.
This is what you should have saved." It's going to help you plan on how to maintain the property, which is one of the primary functions of condominium association. To the extent your association may be three habitable stories or taller, you may also need to have a SIRS report at turnover. SIRS is a Structural Integrity Reserve Study. And that's going to be the primary budgeting tool for condominiums because those are required by statute for those buildings that are three stories or taller. And it has to be included as part of your budget going forward. And that dictates, again, there are components to a SIRS that are required by statute.
A condominium of three stories or taller must reserve for the roof, electrical systems, fireproofing systems, painting, components like that. And so that SIRS report at the turnover tells you exactly what you need to have saved, when that component's going to need replacing so that you have the money to do it at that time. And if we'll move on to the next slide. Jim, let me ask you something before we go further. Let's talk about timing. At the point of the transition meeting, let's talk about condos first.
What is a developer required to turn over at the time of the meeting? Or I can answer my own question. Yeah, maybe. All right. So there's an anomaly between condos and HOAs. For condos, all of the records of the association are required to be turned over at turnover other than the audit, which the developer has 90 days to complete and present after turnover.
So all of the documents that Jim talked about, the source documents, source accounting records, the list of owners, the list of contractors, the as-built plans and specifications, contracts, all of those have to be turned over at the time of turnover. You may get a receipt provided to sign off on for those. Now the audit can come 90 days later. Developer would still be in compliance. The anomaly for homeowners associations, which legislature has never corrected, is the HOA statute actually says the developer's got 90 days to produce all of the documents for turnover. And that's one of the things I've never understood is, that literally means that the checkbook for the association doesn't have to be turned over for 90 days, and then here you are at the new developer board trying to operate your HOA, and the developer says, "Well, I don't have to turn over the checkbook for 90 days." Well, who pays the bills?
Anyway, most developers of HOAs do turn over a number of documents at the time of turnover, but for some reason, the legislature gave them the leeway to have additional time. But condos, all those documents other than the audit have to be delivered at the time of turnover. Sorry to interrupt, Jim. No, very good points. And so that's primarily the initial turnover process. That's what's going to get your board the information it needs to start running your association.
Because that's what this is all about, putting you in control of your association and allowing the members to control their own destiny, so to speak. So we've gone through the initial turnover process. You have your member board in place. What does it look like the first year or so after that board takes over? Obviously, that board's going to spend a lot of time trying to get up to speed. They're going to be dumped into a role where they have to manage this association regardless of the troubles it may have.
And post-turnover, that can be pretty extreme. You may have construction defect issues to deal with. You may have a developer who hasn't complied with records turnovers or the statutory turnover requirements, or if you're an HOA, the government-driven turnover requirements. And so they may have not just operational concerns to deal with, but they may have litigation or turnover related issues to deal with, too. So it can be pretty complicated. You want to go to the next slide.
The first thing you need to do is basically understand your governing documents. Again, you've been given now your declaration bylaws articles. Those are the core operational documents of your association. Your bylaws tell you how to operate meetings and how to internally operate the association. Your declaration is the contract. The declaration as it will be, the constitution as some courts call it, of the association which dictates how owners are supposed to maintain their property, how the association's supposed to collect and maintain assessments, reserves, budgeting.
You're going to find a lot of that ultimately dealt with in the governing documents. For condominiums, you're also going to find a lot of detail in Chapter 718 of the Florida Statutes, as again, condos are really regulated by statute where HOAs are going to be focusing on their governing documents. But that's the problem that new directors are going to be confronted with, and that's understanding and operating the association within the bounds of those documents and the law. Hiring counsel is a great idea. Hiring a CAM, or whether you need to transition from the developer's CAM if they're still in place. But making sure that you have a qualified manager in place to assist you, that you have qualified counsel to assist you with legal questions, that you have a qualified accountant to help you with financial problems.
Assembling that team is going to be a part of getting up to speed and operating your association. I often advocate for clients to say, "Hey, an email to your lawyer or your accountant is a lot cheaper than trying to unwind the mistake you made by not getting the information in advance." So ask the questions before you commit to a course of action if you're unsure. It's going to save you a lot of time and money down the road. We can advise about enforcement. Really anything operationally speaking, general counsel such as our firm, we can do that for you. Accountants, we're not going to talk to you about money or taxes or anything like that.
That's why you're going to need a qualified accountant. And as far as CAMs go, they're going to be your day-to-day operational asset. They're the boots on the ground for you. They're going to be the ones driving around the community looking for violations. They're going to be your main point of contact with the membership. It's going to be very important that you interact with these people and get good quality people in place.
And so that's part of the new director's job, ensuring that they have that proper team. Next slide. And again, another component of that job is going to be enforcing turnover and holding the developer accountable for anything that they may have done wrong, prior to turnover, through turnover, or if they're still involved with your community after turnover, which does occur. You may need to keep them honest. That may be construction defect claims, which Taylor's going to talk to you a bit about. It may be, again, disgorging money.
Maybe they shortchanged you. Maybe they need to pay you something. Maybe they haven't given you documents. Again, pursuing those claims against the developer is also going to be an obligation for the first board and maybe the next successive couple of boards too until it quiets down and you just have a general HOA or condominium to run. And I think with that, I'll turn it over to Taylor, who's going to talk to you a bit more about claims against developers for engineering and things like that. Thank you, Jim.
I'm going to take the next three topics, and they're really one story told in three parts. Find out what you actually own, find out what happened to your money, and three, then decide what to do about it. Let's start with the engineering investigation. If you're a condominium, the developer handed you a turnover inspection report at the turnover meeting. Since 2024, that's actually two reports, one covering the roof, structure, fireproofing, plumbing, electrical, waterproofing, windows, doors, and the other covering elevators, air conditioning, pools, sea walls, pavement, drainage, and irrigation. That sounds comprehensive.
It really isn't. What the statute asks that report to tell you is the condition, the useful life, and replacement cost of those items. In other words, it's a reserve study. It's a visual look. It's performed by the developer's professional, paid for by the developer, and designed to satisfy the developer's obligation, not to protect you. And here's a pattern that we see over and over again.
The developer's engineer flies a drone over the roof. They count three broken tiles, and they write, "Roof, remaining useful life, 20 years." Developer replaces the three tiles and announces that everything in the report has been addressed. The new board says, "Well, we already have an engineering report. We don't need another one." That is the trap. Nobody can tell you from a drone whether the tiles are fastened correctly, whether the flashing was done right, or whether the underlayment was installed at all. You only learn that by getting up on that roof and where the evidence points, opening it up.
If you're a homeowners' association, it's simpler. The statute doesn't require the developer to give you an engineering report at all. Poor plans. You start from zero. So the independent investigation is even more important if you're an HOA.
So what does a real investigation look like? You hire a forensic engineer, not a reserve specialist, who pulls the permit drawings from the building department, walks every building and every site element, does targeted destructive testing, and measures what was built against three yardsticks, the Florida Building Code, the permitted plans, and the industry standard of care. Those yardsticks matter because they're what a developer will actually pay for. It doesn't look right is not a legal claim. The stuff that was installed without a weep screen, in violation of the building code, is a viable legal claim. Three practical points.
First, it's important to do this in the first year. The warranty and limitation periods I'll cover in a few minutes are running, and a good investigation takes months. Second, use two different firms, one for the reserve study and one for the defect investigation. We've seen an engineer on the witness stand, having found serious roof defects, forced to explain why a reserve study he wrote the same month gave that same roof 20 years of life. Don't hand a developer that sort of cross-examination. Third, retain the engineer through construction counsel, so the working drafts and communications are protected while the investigation is underway.
Last thing, if you never make a claim, this report is still your baseline. It's what the board budgets from, and it's your business judgment protection when an owner later asks why the board did or did not do something. Florida courts protect boards that investigate before they decide. This is that investigation. Next slide.
So now let's follow the money. Both the Condominium Act and the HOA Act require the developer to deliver an audit of the association's books from the day the association was incorporated through the date of turnover. For a condo, at the turnover meeting. For an HOA, within 90 days. And the statutes tell the auditor to do two specific things, examine the cash disbursements and paid invoices to determine whether every expenditure was for an association purpose, and examine the billings and receipts to determine whether the developer was charged and actually paid the proper assessments. Those are the right questions.
The problem is who's asking them. The developer selects the CPA, pays that CPA, and supplies the records. So treat the turnover audit from the developer just like you would a seller's inspection report when you buy a house. Read it, but don't rely on it. Hire your own CPA, one who does association work, for a forensic review of the developer control period. What do they find?
Here are some recurring items. Developer expenses paid with association money, sales office electricity, the landscaping and pressure washing around the models, marketing, and a big one, repairs of construction defects the developer should have paid for out of its own pocket, but which were run through the association's operating account as maintenance. Unpaid assessments on unsold units and lots. Many developers use what's called a guarantee. Developer's excused from paying assessments in exchange for promising that owner assessments won't exceed a stated amount and for funding whatever deficit results. Very often, when a CPA actually reconciles the guarantee period, the developer has not funded the full deficit.
And for a condominium, that deficit includes the full funding of reserves. And another point on reserves. Since the 2022 post-surfside legislation, a developer-controlled condominium association cannot vote to waive or reduce reserves at all. If the budgets during developer control show reserves waived or half-funded, that is money owed. And an HOA, it depends on your documents. But if the declaration required the developer to fund reserves or deficits, that obligation is enforceable.
And then the miscellaneous. Working capital contributions collected at closings that never reached the association, insurance proceeds, deposits, and vendor bills left unpaid for the new board to discover. A recent fourth DCA case shows how this plays out. In a Vero Beach homeowners association, the owners took control, and they sued the developer for failing to fund reserves and for underpaying its annual deficit obligation. In 2024, the appellate court threw out the reserve claim because the board, not the developer, controlled the budget. It threw out the claims against the developer's appointed directors because being appointed by the developer is not in and of itself bad faith.
But the deficit funding claim survived because the declaration put that obligation squarely on the developer. And there are two takeaways from that case. The documents make or break these claims, and the court held that the claim accrued every year the developer underpaid, even before turnover, and limited the recovery to the five years before suit. HOAs get no tolling. Every year you wait, a year of recovery falls off the back end. So the bottom line is this.
Get your own CPA during the first year. Give them the engineering report so they can spot defect repairs charged to the association and give the results to construction counsel. That's the second half of the claim package. Next slide.
So now you have an engineering report and a CPA review, and the board has a decision to make. Let me walk through what the potential claims are, how to pursue, and the deadlines, because the deadlines really drive everything. The claims fall generally into three buckets. First, construction defects. If you're a condominium, you have statutory warranties from the developer and contractors, most of which run three years from the certificate of occupancy or one year after turnover, whichever is later, plus possible negligence and building code claims. If you're an HOA, you don't have those statutory warranties.
And since 2012, the legislature has eliminated implied warranties for off-site improvements like roads and drainage. You're generally left with breach of contract, negligence, and code violations, which since 2023 must be material violations. That is something that has caused or reasonably could cause injury or significant damage to the building's performance. Second bucket of claims are the financial claims we just discussed. And the third are the turnover claims, meaning records, plans, or the audit that was never delivered. For a condo, the division will enforce those.
For an HOA, it's a trip to the courthouse. How are these claims pursued? Construction claims in Florida go through a pre-suit process under Chapter 55A. Construction counsel serves a detailed notice of claim. For an association with more than 20 parcels, that's at least 120 days before suit. The developer and the contractors get to inspect, and they have to respond with a repair offer, a settlement offer, or a denial.
That process resolves a number of cases, and while it's running, the clock on your deadlines is paused. If it doesn't resolve, you can file suit, and the real target then is usually the insurance. Now, the deadlines. There are two, both in Florida Statute Section 95.11. And there's been a change here since we last presented this topic, which is somewhat significant. The statute of limitations is four years.
Under a 2023 statutory amendment, the statute of limitations now runs from the earliest of the issuance of a temporary certificate of occupancy, the certificate of occupancy, or certificate of completion, in some instances, abandonment, which will rarely be applicable in your circumstances. For a hidden latent defect, the four years runs from when you discovered that defect or should have discovered it with due diligence. So that's the statute of limitations. In addition to that, though, there is an outer wall, and that's the statute of repose. It used to be 10 years here in Florida. Since 2023, it's now only seven years from that same earliest date of triggering events, basically the certificates of occupancy.
And it doesn't matter when you discover the defect or whether anyone could have. Seven years go by, and the courthouse door closes. There is, though, one minor potentially helpful detail. If you're in a multi-building project, each building gets its own clock. And now a condominium wrinkle, and it's a good one.
For condominiums, but not HOAs, Section 718.124 says neither the limitations period nor, since 2024, the repose period, begins to run until the owners elect a majority of the board. A condo board gets a fresh clock at turnover. Now, a bill filed earlier this year to take away that repose tolling died in committee. I would not necessarily count on it staying dead. And for HOAs, unfortunately, there's no tolling at all. If your developer built the first phase eight years ago and turned over last month, the defect claims on that phase are in all likelihood barred.
So if you take one thing away from my segment this morning, it's this: the first year after turnover is when this work needs to get done. A few closing points from me. Read your documents before you act. Developer-drafted declarations sometimes require an owner vote before the association can sue the developer, and general counsel needs to deal with that early. Don't sign anything at turnover that reads like a release, and don't accept "we fixed everything" report as a sellout. Warranty repairs by a developer are welcome, but you're only obligated to allow a competent, permanent repair, not beads of caulk.
Keep a claims file. Dates, photographs, notices, responses. And talk to construction counsel early. Most of these engagements are structured so that the association is not funding the case entirely out of pocket. And every dollar recovered is a dollar that owners don't have to special assess.
And with that, I will hand it back over to Jim. Jim, before you get started, one addendum. If you're an HOA and you want to file litigation that has a value of more than $100,000, before you can file suit, there is a requirement for an owner vote to approve going forward with any litigation where there's $100,000 or more at issue. So there's one additional hurdle for HOAs. That requirement does not apply to condos. The board of directors would have the authority to initiate a construction defect or accounting suit, no matter what the value of the claim is, but HOAs do have that hoop to jump through.
I agree. Go on, Jim.
So I'm going to just talk about our last topic for the day, which is document amendments and how post-turnover, an association may want to consider either amending its declaration or bylaws, and some other factors. So when a developer creates your community, they record the declaration. When they create the association, they submit articles of incorporation to the state. And then to operate the association, they have to have bylaws. Some of those documents, for example, the articles and bylaws, can be relatively minimal. They may not always have the information you need to really understand how to operate your association.
So those two things can sometimes require immediate amendment to get out the statement to make sure they're effective documents.
The declaration is going to come to you perhaps already with several amendments and you have to consider it's going to have a lot of developer-based language, especially if you're an HOA. Because the declaration is the operational government, and even while under developer control, it dictates how the developer has to behave and how the membership has to treat the developer in return. So you're going to get a document that is primarily based around the developer operating the association.
Eventually, you are going to need to amend that document to remove the developer references. Eventually, that is just going to become a confusing problem for your association. Twenty years later, it's still talking about developer language, your membership's not going to know what the heck is going on.
However, you can't necessarily amend that all out right away. Your developer may still have some post-turnover obligations for a while. They may still have some rights as far as reserved rights to provide garbage collection services or certain things like that. They may have continuing obligations, and as long as they own some units, they may reserve the right to be exempt from certain architectural controls or assessments for HOAs under certain circumstances. And again, some of those things will need to be in place as long as the developer has some active involvement in your community. As much as we want to get rid of that stuff as quickly as possible, you may need to allow it to hang on for a while.
Now, that doesn't mean you can't still amend your declaration and documents a little bit earlier if you have new problems that need to be addressed. For example, if the community wants to instill new restrictions on short-term rentals, your developer built this thing, no restriction on rentals, now you have 90% of the units occupied by members, and you decide that you don't want to have short-term party rentals in your condo. You can still enact those changes, those amendments. You have to do it in accordance with the governing documents. But by and large, your developer's not going to interfere with your right to do that. Occasionally, developers will reserve the right to approve amendments even after turnover, so long as they own units.
So again, it can get pretty complicated as far as timing, the method of amendment, and stuff like that. But eventually, you are certainly going to want to amend your governing documents to remove the developer and to more accurately represent what the membership wants. And of course, that's the purpose of turnover is to put the membership in charge of the community, and dictating what those restrictions are is a big part of that.
And of course, rules and regulations. As I mentioned earlier, your developer may have generated rules and regulations. That's not common. We don't really see rules and regulations. That's clubhouse rules, that's the right to speak at meetings, things like that. We don't often see that level of detail from developers.
But either even if they presented you with rules or if they gave you nothing, the association may have a vested interest in very quickly adopting some rules because declarations leave some voids. They may set out a rule but not give you the process for how to evaluate a problem. Your rules can fill in those gaps, and that's the purpose of rules.
So, that is probably the one document you want to consider generating pretty quickly after turnover. Otherwise, work with counsel to evaluate your current documents and figure out what you should change now, what you can change now, and just come up with a plan for how to do that effectively so that as quickly as possible, you've really taken control of your community and your membership has the ability to know what's going on.
And with that, I think we still have about five minutes for questions. We've answered some in the chat. I don't know what's popped up since I started talking here, but...
Yeah, Jim, let me raise a couple of issues of the more attitudinal issues. So I'm sure what's gone through a lot of people's minds as they listen to it is not only are we going to find after transition that the developer understated the operational budget, but now we have these lawyers telling us about all these things we should be doing within the first year, getting engineering studies, getting a CPA involved, certainly involving lawyers in amendment processes. So the financial challenge is daunting, and we're perfectly understandable of this.
One of the things that some groups do, rather than raise assessments, is actually draw on a line of credit to take care of some of the short-term needs during the first year that would not be recreated over the course of an association's life. And an example would be if you were a for-profit corporation that was building a new warehouse. You probably wouldn't take the cost of the warehouse out of your general operating account. You would probably get financing for it because it's a one-time expenditure that's not going to be recreated. Well, an analogy in the association world is there's a lot of these extraordinary expenses that are only going to be incurred within the first year. You get financing to cover those, you spread the cost of them over time, and if it's a claim situation, obviously there may be a recovery within a couple of years that could satisfy a line of credit that you've taken out.
The other point is the communication to the owners about getting a CPA, getting a lawyer, doing an engineering investigation, and the owners are like, "You folks are totally out of control spending our money." And an appropriate line for a board member at that point to consider is, "Look, I have just been given, or we have just been given the responsibility for millions of dollars worth of infrastructure to oversee it, to maintain it. We are now in charge of the association finances, all of these obligations that we have. And in order for us to do that job competently, we need the support of professionals, lawyers, CPAs, accountants, certainly a great management company. And we're going to need to spend what's necessary in order to properly set our association on a course for a great future and to protect our values. And if we don't have proper information, it's less likely we're going to make the great decisions that you want us to make as your board going forward." So be prepared attitudinally to understand that especially in 2026, people are going to be looking at the assessments, and that's going to be their major concern. But the fiduciary obligation to properly operate the association is on your backs.
So be prepared to deal with those concerns, and especially with statute of limitations that we've talked about and statute of repose, waiting is not on your side. So things need to happen within that first year. So sometimes being straight with the owners about what your burdens are as a board member is really important. So, we have a couple of minutes. I didn't see any questions.
One person asked a question about, "Can a developer give up control and try to take it back?" There are protections against that, and there's case law about that.
Well, I'll cut in there. That is actually our client's end. It's subject to some pretty unusual circumstances. Okay. So we can deal with that with our client in private to deal with some circumstances. That one is particularly odd, and it's not retaking control in the way you may think from a turnover perspective.
But the other question I did see pop up was whether a developer needs to pay the reserves for vacant units pre-turnover when that happens, and it gets specified as a condo. You may have something to say about the exceptions. I will say that the general rule is that a developer is treated as a unit owner in condominiums before turnover and is generally required to contribute proper assessments for the unit. But I think there certainly are some exceptions to that rule, and there are some budgeting methods that even condo developers can use to maybe limit that impact. I don't know, Adam, do you have any experience with some of those odd exceptions? I know HOAs certainly have a different financing method, but... No, I think you covered it.
Okay, at this juncture, we are going to say goodbye. This transcript and the video will be posted on our website within a week, so your other board members and fellow managers can have access to it.
And with that, hopefully, this has been helpful for pre-turnover groups in the middle of turnover and post-turnover. And we issue all the courage and fortitude to people who have just taken over their association as the initial board and dealing with all the challenges that you're facing the first year, and we and other professionals are here to support you. Thank you very much, folks. Thank you all